Roald Dahl's child-versus-witches story has produced two features that change its setting, effects, protagonist, and final consequences in different ways.
This map covers the related screen works currently supported by PlotGeeks, rather than every adaptation ever made.
2020 | Feature filmThe WitchesAdapted from | Robert Zemeckis
The later adaptation relocates the story to 1960s Alabama, changes the boy and grandmother's background, and restores a less reversible ending.
Why read this explainer
For this book and film pair, the useful question is how the book version of The Witches changes in the film version, The Witches. The comparison is strongest around the film changes the book's final state, while the film condenses the plan against children into a clearer hotel confrontation..
PlotGeeks note
The film changes the book's final state: The film offers a softer reversal, turning the final state into rescue rather than lasting transformation.
Connected knowledge
Connected in PlotGeeks
Verified paths from The Witches: Book to Film to closely related explainers and browse pages.
Family can offer shelter, impose a role, or become the system a character must escape.
At a glance
Book and film, fast
Same coreWhat both versions keep
A boy and his grandmother uncover a secret gathering of witches who plan to transform children into mice.
Biggest changeThe book is stranger and colder
The film leans into grotesque performance and visual menace.
CompressionWhat the film has to condense
The film condenses the plan against children into a clearer hotel confrontation.
Ending shiftThe film changes the book's final state
The film offers a softer reversal, turning the final state into rescue rather than lasting transformation.
Start hereEither version works first
Read first if you want the darker ending. Watch first for the creature effects and hotel thriller shape.
Closer comparison
Book and film side by side
The film changes the book's final state
In the book
The novel leaves the boy transformed and still loved.
In the film
The film offers a softer reversal, turning the final state into rescue rather than lasting transformation.
The book is stranger and colder
In the book
The novel treats danger and tenderness side by side.
In the film
The film leans into grotesque performance and visual menace.
Both keep the grandmother bond
In the book
The book uses that bond to make the ending tender.
In the film
The film keeps the bond while making the adventure more reassuring.
Source to screen
From The Witches to The Witches
The film changes the book's final state
The novel leaves the boy transformed and still loved. The film offers a softer reversal, turning the final state into rescue rather than lasting transformation.[1][2]
The film changes the book's final state
The novel leaves the boy transformed and still loved. The film offers a softer reversal, turning the final state into rescue rather than lasting transformation.
Sources
Source trail
These links verify the book, film, and adaptation relationship. The comparison notes are original PlotGeeks prose.